Home Home Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingle Roof: Pros And Cons

Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingle Roof: Pros And Cons


Choosing the right type of roof for your house has always been a difficult decision to make. From the plethora of roofing options available in the market, the big decision always comes down to choosing one out of the two, either a metal roof or an asphalt shingle roof.

Both of the roofing types have their pros and cons that are unmatched by others, but it depends completely on what your needs are and what location are you living in to install them.

To make the process of selection easier for you, here is a comparison of metal roofing vs asphalt shingles.

How Expensive Is It?

Metal Roof

The average cost of metal roofs ranges from anywhere between $2000-$5000 depending on the quality of the roof you are opting for.

You can opt for a different material depending on the needs of how strong and durable a roofing option you want to go for. Aluminium and copper roofs are known to be the most durable options out of the metal roofing and can go fairly up in prices.

Asphalt Shingle Roof

Asphalt shingle roofs are the top favorite choice of homeowners and contractors alike mostly because of the low installation costs.

It can be as low as a quarter of installing a metal roof. The price variation in asphalt shingle roofs does not depend on the different materials used, but on the number of layers, you want to add to your roof for stronger durability.

Ease Of Installation

Metal Roof

The installation of metal roofs is a rather complex task, to begin with. There are a large number of tiles that need to be placed in a precise manner, with several gaskets and screws to put in place.

It is necessary to hire a professional metal roof contractor for the installation of it because of its technicality, and cannot be done by yourself or a cheap handyman.

Asphalt Shingle Roof

The installation of asphalt shingle roofs, on the contrary, is known to be one of the easiest and simplest of tasks.

Although the best-recommended option would be to entrust and able professional for the task, it can, however, be performed by a local handyman or yourself after gathering knowledge from several tutorial videos or informative articles from over the internet.


Metal Roof

The best pro factor a metal roof gives to you is the long-lasting life that it offers. Some top quality metal roofs are known to last well over a century of the year, which slightly a little more than your lifetime!

The average lifespan of a metal roof with adequate care ranges from 80 years to well over a hundred years, which should give you a decent return on your high investment in the first place.

Asphalt Shingle Roof

Although the asphalt shingles offer a decent amount of years for the investment they require initially, they are still nothing compared to the long-lasting durability of a metal roof.

An average asphalt shingle roof can last somewhere between 18 and 20 years, which is even less than a quarter of the lifespan of a metal roof.


Metal Roof

The maintenance requirements of a metal roof are quite minimal since no valleys are forming or the issue of it crumbling away.

The usual roof leaks are quite rare to encounter and can be fixed by simply replacing the broken gasket or tightening a tile screw. Although finding the affected gasket or screw can be a pain on itself, to begin with, but once found, it is an easy fix.

Asphalt Shingle Roof

The maintenance requirements of the asphalt shingle roof start to add up and multiply over the years. because of the lack of commodities like metal roofing supplies for metal roofs, the leaks have to be dealt with professionally.

You can expect to encounter several problems with an average asphalt shingle roof if you have a roof leak due to water seepage, you are looking at a major expense of either waterproofing your roof, or adding an entirely new layer to your roof.

Because of the flat nature of the asphalt shingle roof, you will be encountered with major obstacles such as the accumulated blockage of drains due to collection of debris, the crumbling away of the roof, and also the depressions caused in the roof over time due to a high weight of trapped water.

Leave a Reply